Rarities and What-Ifs are tracks that are either rare or have a hidden history or story behind them.
| Title | Artists | Album | Year | |
| 201 | The Core | Eric Clapton | Slowhand | 1977 |
| 202 | No Way | David Gilmour | David Gilmour | 2006 |
| 203 | Fährmann | Godewind | 20 Johr Platt ‘n Roll | 2005 |
| 204 | One Step Back | Dave Edmunds | Plugged In | 1994 |
| 205 | Catfish Stroll | The Catfish | Blackjack | 1992 |
| 206 | River Song | Dennis Wilson | Pacific Ocean Blue | 1977 |
| 207 | All Lovers Are Deranged | David Gilmour | About Face | 2006 |
| 208 | Helden | Carom | Carom | 1993 |
| 209 | Broadsword | Jethro Tull | The Broadsword And The Beast | 1982 |
| 210 | Boogie All The Time | Vince Weber | Boogie On A Blue Song | 1987 |
| 211 | Happy Song | Three Dog Night | Cyan | 1973 |
| 212 | Outer Circle | Martin Barre | The Meeting | 1996 |
| 213 | Call Me The Breeze | Lynyrd Skynyrd | Second Helping | 1973 |
| 214 | Headlines | John Fogerty | Eye Of The Zombie | 1986 |
| 215 | Just A John | Loudon Wainwright III | Grown Man | 1995 |
| 216 | Dun Ringill | Jethro Tull | Stormwatch | 1979 |
| 217 | Travelled | Supertramp | Indelibly Stamped | 1971 |
| 218 | Liek mit de Sünn | Godewind | 20 Johr Platt ‘n Roll | 2005 |
| 219 | Radio | Wise Guys | Radio | 2006 |
| 220 | Joy To The World | Three Dog Night | Joy To The World: Their Greatest Hits | 1975 |
| 221 | Help Me Down That Road | Supertramp | Some Things Never Change | 1997 |
| 222 | Tatort | Passport | Passport Live | 2000 |
| 223 | Bonny Black Hare | Steeleye Span | Live At A Distance | 2009 |
| 224 | Another Man’s Woman | Supertramp | Crisis? What Crisis? | 1976 |